The Black Throne, by Fred Saberhagen and Roger Zelazny
pros: the authors; the story idea; story moves along quickly; twist on magic and parallel worlds; explanations for some of Poe’s elements in poems, like the tapping and the raven and the cask of Amontillado
cons: sketchy details; seems hastily written; not familiar with Poe’s body of work; resolution was weak
misc: Edgar Allan Poe; alcoholic; alcohol; ghost ship; sea voyage; balloon voyage; vortex; plague; dwarf; orangutang; zombie in wine box; very small wineglasses; sandcastle; alchemy
ISBN 0743435796; 288pp; pub. 2002
Amazon link
Territory, by Emma Bull
pros: author; well-written story with great characters; historical setting is realistic and believable and details of area and time are very good; great idea; plenty of action but still doesn’t feel like a typical fast-paced action fantasy; Chu; newspaper details
cons: ending leaves me hanging; I would have liked to see more details about Jesse’s abilities and his lessons with Chow Lung; would have liked some more details of the conflicts between the various wizard factions
misc: OK Corral; Tombstone; Wyatt Earp; Cochise County; silver mine; Chinatown; Mildred/Millie; typesetter; Nuggest; Tombstone Epitaph; cowboys; ranchers; Mexican border
ISBN 0312857357; 320pp; pub. 2007
Amazon link
The Anubis Gates, by Tim Powers
pros: well-written; fun to read; interesting characters; twisty plot; the character Jacky; the ending; Coleridge in the dungeons; special shoes for villains and chains on the feet for the good guys; some of the names; some very creepy bad guys, especially the clown
cons: the bad guys were a little spread out; Brendan’s doppleganger/ka dopeyness didn’t fit with the explanations of what happens to a ka and his ultimate fate is also inconsistent but convenient; I didn’t fully understand where the “master” came from, he just seemed like a convenient arch-enemy
misc: misfiring gun; ear loss; London in 1800s; Egypt; British and French occupation of Egypt; time travel; time as an ice flow over weeds in a river; gypsies; a wooden monkey; motorcycle crash; soul-shifting; hairy apemen; spells/sorcery gone awry; werewolf isn’t really a werewolf but a sorcerer sort of turned into a dog who keeps growing long hair all over his body and he shifts bodies about once a week because of the hair; Brendan Doyle; William Ashbless; poetry and poets; Punch and Judy show; Dr. Romany; Lord Byron
ISBN 0441004016; 400pp; pub. 1997
Swordspoint, by Ellen Kushner
pros: the prose; Richard and Alec’s romance/relationship is twisted but interesting; well-drawn decadence; excellent characterizations; swordsmen as professional duelists acting for nobility isn’t new, but point of view of swordsmen and their life is more detailed than usual; not so much an antihero as antiheroic
cons: homosexual romance, although beautifully written, was too much for my tastes and distracted from the story – it would have been enough to establish their particular preferences, that this world accepts same sex relationships as totally mundane, and that Richard does apparently care about someone; intrigue, drama, and violence are a major part of story; fascination with violence and blood presented as a sexually desirable trait; some predictability
ISBN 368pp; pub. 2003 (paperback edition)
A Night in the Lonesome October, by Roger Zelazny
pros: it’s by Zelazny; animal characters, especially Snuff, the dog; use of literary and historical characters like Sherlock Holmes, a druid, Cain, Dr. Frankenstein (I may not have recognized all of them); action; dog hero’s “rounds”; surprise with the rat; catnappery world of dreams; portrayal of story from animals’ viewpoints
cons: I didn’t care for the ending, it was both a little anticlimactic and predictable; I didn’t like that one particular character dies; Holmes was annoying; a little confusing at times (it is a Zelazny, after all); end of the world threat sort of fizzles out, doesn’t really work as driving conflict in story; a little negative about cats’ nature
ISBN 0380771411; 280 pp; pub. 1994
Click to Subscribe
